Punch Drunk Restraint Training Design
One of the key questions we have asked our colleagues in the field of training, as we have visited with them to share our approach is: “What stimulus are you preparing your staff to respond to?”
The question is somewhat oblique, but it focusses on the heart of the matter - what do we want our attendees to learn? For example our colleague Mark Dawes undertook a detailed study of the ways in which a cohort of 356 nurses from one NHS Trust had been assaulted.
Mark asked these nurses how they had been physically assaulted in the line of their work, and found that “in the vast majority of cases nursing staff were facing impact type assaults from a front-on position”. Other studies have found that being being attacked by a punch or a slap or kick accounted for over half of the incidents of assault on nursing staff.
This is what we mean by our question “To what stimulus are you preparing your staff to
respond?” because in a breakaway training programme, the stimulus we want to prepare our staff for must be the most probable attack they are likely to face, if they are assaulted.
However, when we look at some of the training programmes some organisations are delivering and the types of technique involved, we have observed that:
- the majority of ‘breakaways’ taught are responses to being grabbed, not the punch or slap
- training course technical repertoires do not deal with impact-type assaults very well, if at all
- training courses do not address pre-assault behaviours (as distinct from aggression signs)
From the field of sports science, we know that for the task of ‘blocking a punch’.:
“Stimulus Identification is the primary information-processing requirement to reduce Reaction Time” (Schmidt and Wrisberg 2008)
So we might then ask - how do we prepare our staff to react more effectively, in the face of studies which show that IF they are assaulted, there is a high probability the attack will be an impact from the front, such as a punch, slap or shove?
We need to look at the relationship between Stimulus Identification and Reaction Time , and how focussing on the pre-assault behaviours and mannerisms of a subject may assist in speeding reaction time.
Our Breakaway course incorporates much of this theory and provides examples of how to incorporate good practice into training design.
———————————————-
Gerard O’Dea is a conflict management, personal safety and physical interventions training consultant. He is the training director for Dynamis, a specialist in personal safety and violence reduction initiatives and the European Adviser for ‘Verbal Defense and Influence’, a global programme which addresses the spectrum of human conflict. www.dynamis.training
Gerard's book on Lone Worker Personal Safety is available on Amazon Kindle and Paperback.
In June 2024, Dynamis Training travelled to the Caribbean to serve as trusted adviser and coach to the Ministry of Health in Trinidad and Tobago. Our mission: to improve outcomes for individuals experiencing emotional or psychological disturbances when they interact with public service staff. The collaboration represented a step towards improving approaches to mental health
Read More
Conflict is an unfortunate reality that healthcare professionals must navigate daily. Whether you’re running a busy GP practice, managing a clinic, overseeing a pharmacy, or working in primary care, the ability to handle challenging situations effectively is crucial. This post delves into key strategies for managing conflict and ensuring the safety of both staff and
Read More
A traditional ‘classroom model’, which has been a cornerstone of education for centuries, emphasises learning and performing skills in a neutral setting. In fields like conflict management and physical restraint training, this model may not be the most effective for your people. Here we evaluate some strengths and weaknesses of the classroom model before contrasting
Read More
A group of NHS Highland trainers have been applying Dynamis’ scenario-driven approach to their PMVA training since 2022 and have experienced some startling results, with one cohort reporting a 72% uplift in confidence about safely breaking away from violent contact. The NHS Highland team reported their experiences at an update to the GSA membership’s annual
Read More
Gerard O'Dea is the Director of Training for Dynamis. Training Advisor, Speaker, Author and Expert Witness on Personal Safety, Conflict Management and Physical Interventions, he is the European Advisor for Vistelar Conflict Management, a global programme focussing on the spectrum of human conflict.