• Home
  • |
  • Blog
  • |
  • Restraint Training: How many people to clean a resisting subject in a bed?

June 8, 2015

Restraint Training: How many people to clean a resisting subject in a bed?

In addition to the issues we have previously identified [ Post 1 ] and [ Post 2 ] in regards to those residents who combatively resist efforts to assist them with personal hygiene (particularly if they have incontinence without awareness of this), one further example of the risk assessment/manual handling issue is that I often hear that a care home has a resident who requires cleaning when they are in bed AND they are resistant to that essential care. My recommendation has always been that cleaning or caring for a mobile person in a bed who is actively resisting those efforts (IF it becomes absolutely necessary to do so) will require perhaps as many as 5 staff to accomplish it using physical holding. The procedure we might suggest to staff for this kind of scenario could require 4 staff to safely hold the subject which then allows 1 staff member to safely carry out the personal hygiene care. In our opinion, with a mobile person who can move their limbs freely, this is the minimum requirement to carry out the task with the maximum of safety, minimum disruption time and the appropriate level of professionalism. One major consideration here is that a team of 5 staff with a good plan can complete the cleaning task in less time with more safety and comfort for the person than a team of 2 staff can with less control and less safety. A team of 5 staff can get 'back on the floor' faster by far than the struggling team of 2 AND leave the client less distressed, more comfortable and safer. Staff often resist the idea that this task might need so many people, however if we ask the question: what is in the resident’s best interests? then I think the answer would be: “To be subjected to any intrusive procedure for the minimum amount of time possible” From both of these perspectives (staff time-on-task and resident time-in-discomfort) then it must be considered how the staff team will achieve their task of cleaning the resistant resident where other non-physical options have been exhausted. ----------------------------------------- Gerard O’Dea is a conflict management, personal safety and physical interventions training consultant.  He is the training director for Dynamis, a specialist provider of personal safety and violence management programmes and the European Adviser for ‘Verbal Defense and Influence’, a global programme which addresses the spectrum of human conflict.  www.dynamis.training

Related Posts

What are the risks of Distressed Behaviour in Care Homes?

Distressed Behaviours in Care Homes – what are the risks?We have met hundreds of care home staff in our training sessions, and this article aims to clarify some of the issues related to managing aggression and violence with older people, or vulnerable adults in care. We recently received gratitude from a client company that achieved a

Read More

How to NOT end up on Panorama; decision making as culture.

Over time, decision-making becomes culture. 💡 If more team-members spoke up, more effectively and more often, how many disasters, scandals and failures could be averted? I was asked recently to help a team whose workplace ended up looking like a disaster-zone, because of the failure of the team – collectively – to make the right decision

Read More

How many people should we train in positive handling in our school?

Questions we often get asked at Dynamis are how many people should we train in positive handling skills? Should we train the whole staff team or should we train a specialist group? There is no specific guidance available about what is the ‘correct’ number of staff to train in positive handling at your school, however there

Read More

Restraint Reduction Outcomes

Restraint Reduction OutcomesThe new trainer team for this service began rolling out their own programme (a four-day, full-spectrum course for their LD/MH setting) to their staff in October.   By December, they had seen dramatic restraint reduction outcomes in key indicators such as time-in-restraint, floor-based-restraints and number-of-restraints for their high-frequency service users.   “The amount of time we

Read More

Gerard O'Dea


Gerard O'Dea is the Director of Training for Dynamis. Training Advisor, Speaker, Author and Expert Witness on Personal Safety, Conflict Management and Physical Interventions, he is the European Advisor for Vistelar Conflict Management, a global programme focussing on the spectrum of human conflict.